Intelligence is not a likable trait in particular. Neither are competence, success, nor the willingness to work hard. These are all to be respected, perhaps envied, but no one will love you for them. At least, that is my conclusion.
The people who feel the most affection towards me also feel a certain condescension, I believe. They consider me their intellectual inferior, in one way or another. I don't blame them; I suppose I really can't. You learn more when you humbly defer, so it's probably better this way, but sometimes I wonder what it would take to get people to acknowledge my thinking.
The problem lies with me, of course. I've never given any indication of being a particularly contemplative person, and when called upon, I can't give voice to my contemplation. This is the meaning of the word "dumb", you know. Mute. Speechless. Like an animal of the field. The universal reaction, when people find my livejournal for the first time, is always this: "Holy crap! Lillian, you actually have thoughts?" ...but not in so many words.
The fact is that I... I think about things a lot? But I can spend my whole life thinking and people still won't be wrong to call me unintelligent. If I never put my thoughts out there, never subject them to the test of scrutiny, I don't know if they would ever hold up logically beyond the safe boundaries of my head. And by keeping them in here, bouncing around inside my skull, I miss the chance to strengthen my reasoning, to temper my views against opposing and similar alike, and make them fit for sharing with other people, viable outside the womb.
So it's not wrong, to assume that I lack thoughts because I cannot speak them. In fact, one may directly cause the other. But it really struck me recently that, contrary to my beliefs, this is not at all a reason why someone wouldn't like me. We don't put as much stock on intelligence as I had assumed.
Especially this whole partner programming business. My new partner (let's call him Z), before he asked me to be his partner, knew nothing of my programming skills except that I used all three of our allotted late days on the very first 429 assignment. Basically, that I was neither diligent nor punctual. You'd think, especially when choosing a programming partner, that you'd want to pick someone with demonstrated success at programming. But no, he was totally content to work with Miss Tardy. And when I think to all my other relationships with people: never once has anything like intellect or competence figured into the equation. No one has ever awarded me more love for doing something smart, nor taken away love for doing something dumb. So maybe I was wrong about this; maybe all the things that I had thought inherently desirable, admirable, are not so at all.
I think intelligence, rather than being a trait that you'd like in those around you, is a trait that you'd like to have yourself. People won't love you just for being smart. In fact, they're more likely to love you if you make them feel smart. Which is ironic, because when people want to be liked, they do so try to show off their knowledge and wisdom. Is all that just counterproductive? Are we only driving affection away?
The people who feel the most affection towards me also feel a certain condescension, I believe. They consider me their intellectual inferior, in one way or another. I don't blame them; I suppose I really can't. You learn more when you humbly defer, so it's probably better this way, but sometimes I wonder what it would take to get people to acknowledge my thinking.
The problem lies with me, of course. I've never given any indication of being a particularly contemplative person, and when called upon, I can't give voice to my contemplation. This is the meaning of the word "dumb", you know. Mute. Speechless. Like an animal of the field. The universal reaction, when people find my livejournal for the first time, is always this: "Holy crap! Lillian, you actually have thoughts?" ...but not in so many words.
The fact is that I... I think about things a lot? But I can spend my whole life thinking and people still won't be wrong to call me unintelligent. If I never put my thoughts out there, never subject them to the test of scrutiny, I don't know if they would ever hold up logically beyond the safe boundaries of my head. And by keeping them in here, bouncing around inside my skull, I miss the chance to strengthen my reasoning, to temper my views against opposing and similar alike, and make them fit for sharing with other people, viable outside the womb.
So it's not wrong, to assume that I lack thoughts because I cannot speak them. In fact, one may directly cause the other. But it really struck me recently that, contrary to my beliefs, this is not at all a reason why someone wouldn't like me. We don't put as much stock on intelligence as I had assumed.
Especially this whole partner programming business. My new partner (let's call him Z), before he asked me to be his partner, knew nothing of my programming skills except that I used all three of our allotted late days on the very first 429 assignment. Basically, that I was neither diligent nor punctual. You'd think, especially when choosing a programming partner, that you'd want to pick someone with demonstrated success at programming. But no, he was totally content to work with Miss Tardy. And when I think to all my other relationships with people: never once has anything like intellect or competence figured into the equation. No one has ever awarded me more love for doing something smart, nor taken away love for doing something dumb. So maybe I was wrong about this; maybe all the things that I had thought inherently desirable, admirable, are not so at all.
I think intelligence, rather than being a trait that you'd like in those around you, is a trait that you'd like to have yourself. People won't love you just for being smart. In fact, they're more likely to love you if you make them feel smart. Which is ironic, because when people want to be liked, they do so try to show off their knowledge and wisdom. Is all that just counterproductive? Are we only driving affection away?
12 comments | Leave a comment